, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
680.

According to the European Union Courts' case law, commitments must be likely to eliminate competition concerns identified and ensure competitive market structures. In particular, contrary to those entered into during the phase II procedure, commitments offered in Phase I are intended not to prevent the creation or strengthening of a dominant position but rather to clearly dispel all serious doubts in that regard. The Commission enjoys a broad discretion in assessing whether these remedies constitute a direct and sufficient response capable of dispelling any such doubts. [279]

681.

In airline cases, slot release commitments are acceptable to the Commission where it is sufficiently clear that actual entry by new competitors that would eliminate any significant impediment to effective competition would occur. For such commitments to be acceptable, the notifying party need not identify a precise new entrant if various competitors express an interest during the administrative procedure in entering the markets concerned in view of the proposed commitments. In this respect, account must be taken of the facts existing at the time when the decision is adopted and not in the light of subsequent events. [280]

682.

The market investigation confirmed that Heathrow is the most congested airport in Europe. Consequently slots at Heathrow are highly valuable, therefore rendering the Slot Commitments very appealing for prospective new entrants.

683.

Indeed, it is extremely unlikely that any prospective new entrant could obtain all the slots necessary to operate the above-mentioned routes to/from Heathrow with a sufficient number of frequencies from the first IATA season. In addition, a new entrant at Heathrow would have no guarantee of obtaining the slots at the best times, allowing for an optimised level of rotation of aircraft. By contrast, the slot allocation mechanism in the Commitments ensures that the prospective new entrant will in all probability receive the requested slots in a window of +/-20/60 minutes.