, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
678.

The Commission agrees with Virgin that train services between Manchester and London do not constitute a valid substitute for air services for connecting passengers. However, the Commission's route-by-route competitive assessment developed in section VI.1.4 only concerns O&D passengers, and not connecting passengers. These connecting passengers do not belong to the Manchester-London O&D market, but to other O&D markets (e.g. Manchester-Los Angeles, Manchester-Tokyo…) depending on the final destination (or true origin) of their journeys. Any detrimental horizontal effect of the Transaction on such connecting passengers would have been caught by the assessment of the effects of the Transaction on O&D routes with an end in Manchester and an end in another city than London, and where the Parties' direct or indirect services would overlap. Yet, as shown in section VI, the Commission's assessment has not revealed horizontal problems on any such routes.

679.

Moreover, the Commission recognizes that post-Transaction, for passengers originating from Manchester and connecting at Heathrow to another destination, only IAG's services will be available for the Manchester-Heathrow leg of such journeys, and that it may entail a vertical issue (i.e. the risk that IAG may restrict access to its Manchester-Heathrow flights for passengers connecting at Heathrow onto services operated by other carriers to certain destinations). However, this vertical issue, which has been assessed in section VI.3, is fully addressed by the SPA Commitment (see below), which will allow other carriers than IAG to offer competitive tickets for indirect journeys originating from Manchester with a connection at Heathrow to the destinations for which foreclosure risks exist. Indeed, the carriers concerned by the foreclosure risk will have the necessary access to IAG's Manchester-Heathrow flights to offer such tickets, since they will be entitled to request the inclusion of the Manchester-Heathrow route into the list of "feeder routes" covered by the Special Prorate Agreement to be entered into with IAG.

2.1.5. Conclusion