, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
630.

Moreover, even if none of bmi's current slots was reallocated for use on the specific route where it is currently used by bmi, there is a certain degree of likelihood that some of bmi's current slots would be reallocated for use on other routes where bmi operates, as explained in Section V.1 especially on routes where the degree of competition and consumers' choice would be low following bmi's insolvency. For example, following bmi's insolvency, a slot currently used by bmi on the Aberdeen-Heathrow route may be reallocated to a carrier other than IAG for entry on the Heathrow-Edinburgh route. This type of transfer, which would be possible in the counterfactual but very unlikely post-Transaction (due to IAG's expected reluctance to sell or lease out slots obtained through the proposed Transaction) would have the same competitive effect on the Heathrow-Edinburgh as if a slot currently used by bmi on the London-Edinburgh route would be channelled to another carrier than IAG for use on the same route. Therefore, even if bmi's slots would inevitably exit all the markets were they are currently used (quod non), the overall causality criterion underpinning the three criteria of the failing firm defence would not be met.

631.

Moreover, on routes where the Parties currently compete against each other and third parties, the counterfactual may result in a more balanced distribution of market shares (and frequencies of service) than the post-Transaction scenario

632.

To conclude, the overall causality criterion is not be fulfilled.

5.

Conclusion on the failing firm defence

633.

It is concluded that the Parties have failed to demonstrate that the deterioration of the competitive structure that follows from the Transaction would not be directly caused by the Transaction. The three-pronged test set out in the Horizontal Merger Guidelines does not appear to be met. Instead, the Transaction would most likely deteriorate competition to an extent beyond the extent of the deterioration that could result from bmi exiting the market. In addition, it appears likely that the negative effects of bmi's bankruptcy would be short term while the negative effects likely to be caused by the Transaction would be structural in nature.

VIII.

Commitments

1.

Commitments submitted by IAG