, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
597.

First of all, the demand stemming from bmi’s fleet would not need to be met by IAG, since it is currently satisfied at bmi’s Heathrow facilities in its entirety, which have spare capacity and are thus rented out to other airlines. [257] Similarly, IAG does not face capacity shortages at its Heathrow facilities, which are also rented-out to other airlines. Therefore nothing suggests that post-Transaction IAG would have an incentive to foreclose bmi’s infrastructures to satisfy its airlines’ needs. Secondly, it should be borne in mind that – as the Parties submit – it is common for carriers to own and use such facilities at the airports where they are based. Consequently, agreements concerning the rental of airport facilities are usually negotiated between airlines bearing in mind the long term relationship between carriers and are thus concluded on a reciprocal basis (i.e. knowing that the lessor at airport X could be the lessee at airport Y and that refusing access at airport X would expose to retaliation at airport Y).

598.

In conclusion, therefore, the horizontal overlaps existing between the Parties' activities on the MRO market do not give rise to serious doubts.

6.3. Vertical relationships

599.

The Transaction does not give rise to vertically affected markets in components maintenance. In relation to line maintenance, if the narrowest hypothetical geographic market definition is considered (i.e. the provision of line maintenance services at individual airports), only the Barcelona El Prat airport would be vertically affected.

600.

However, no supply relationship exists between the Parties at the above-mentioned airport, at which IAG estimates that it provides around [60-70]-[70-80]% of line maintenance services to third parties. bmi estimates that it accounts for less than [10-20]% of demand for line maintenance services from third parties at Barcelona El Prat.

601.

The Transaction would not lead to input foreclosure at Barcelona El Prat, as there are alternative credible suppliers of line maintenance services, including Lufthansa.

602.

In addition, if a wider geographic market were considered, there would be a greater number of alternative suppliers to IAG, including at other airports which serve the city of Barcelona, such as Girona and Reus, as well as other airports located throughout Spain.