Virgin argues that the costs of such strategy, which would stem from the risk of losing passengers on short-haul flights, would likely not outweigh its benefits, notably because margins on long-haul flights are understood to be significantly greater than on short-haul flights. Virgin also referred to bmi's market power on certain feeder routes (not limited to routes where the Parties' operations overlap), which would be marginally constrained by the possibility that passengers might be able and willing to reach their final destinations through hubs other than Heathrow, and which would allow IAG to effectively foreclose other carrier's access to feeder traffic from routes currently operated by bmi.
According to Virgin, a foreclosure strategy affecting feeder traffic would harm consumers in that it would bring prices up for indirect journeys on itineraries affected by foreclosure, and it would relax competitive constraint exerted on IAG on both these indirect itineraries and their long-haul segments out of Heathrow.
3.3. Commission's assessment
IAG is a major long-haul carrier out of Heathrow. In the Summer 2011 IATA season, it ranked first amongst long-haul carriers in terms of number of passengers carried out of Heathrow, carrying 4.7 million passengers, i.e. more than three times as many passengers as the second carrier, Virgin (1.3 million passengers). bmi, for its part, focuses on short-haul and mid-haul routes and from these routes, provides significant feeder traffic to a range of long-haul carriers. As shown by the table below, the feeder traffic provided by bmi and the combined traffic provided by the Parties account for significant shares of the total number of passengers carried on certain long-haul routes by certain carriers. For example, in 2011, more than [10-20]% of the passengers carried by Air Canada on its Heathrow-Toronto route was carried by bmi on its "feeder routes".
Table 39 provides an overview of feeder traffic provided by the Parties to other carriers for a range of international routes where IAG operates. These routes and carriers have been selected on the basis of thresholds reflecting the importance of the feeder traffic provided by the Parties relative to the total number of passengers travelling on the services provided by the carrier in question on the route [229] , as well as on the basis of the market investigation.