Moreover, shuffling power does not necessarily have only anti-competitive effects. Indeed, it can allow a carrier to react flexibly to changes in demand patterns or events such as exits or entries. Such adaptability can deliver benefits to consumers in particular in that it can allow for quick adaptation of supply to demand. In its analysis of developments that occurred in 2011 on the Heathrow-Glasgow route, IAG indicated that it increased capacity on this route following bmi's exit, which seems to have had at least partially positive effects to consumers.
In addition, the Commission notes that no concrete example of exclusionary practices by IAG through slot shuffling has been brought forward in the course of the procedure. Moreover, such exclusionary practices would have a cost for IAG, which would have to reduce frequencies or modify schedules on certain routes in order to add frequencies or modify schedule on another route to harm a competitor.
Finally, as regards the loyalty-inducing effects of IAG's stronger presence at Heathrow, the Commission considers that the Transaction does not seem likely to bring about adverse effects through enhanced attractiveness of IAG's frequent flyer programme due to IAG's expanded operations at London Heathrow post-Transaction. Indeed, the market investigation indicates that frequent flyer programme rewards are a criterion of minor importance, at least on the routes where the Parties both currently offer direct services, amongst all the criteria used by consumers to choose a flight. As regards corporate customers, they usually do not benefit from frequent flyer programme rewards, which generally accrue to their employees. Therefore, the attractiveness of IAG's frequent flyer programme does not seem likely to deter passengers from choosing other carriers' services out of Heathrow to any significant extent.
In any event, since the number of slots acquired by IAG as a result of the Transaction (i.e. in addition to those it would acquire in the counterfactual) is limited compared to its current slot holding, the number of additional flights that IAG would be able to offer out of Heathrow as a result of the Transaction is also limited. As a result, the loyalty inducing effects of the Transaction through IAG's frequent flyer programme, corporate contracts and travel agent commission systems is very unlikely to be material.