According to Virgin, the further concentration of slots in the hands of IAG following the Transaction may limit the ability of IAG's current and future competitors to achieve an efficient scale at London Heathrow. However, due to the limited increment in IAG's slot holding due to the Transaction (all the more so when IAG's commitments are taken into account), the limitation resulting from the Transaction on other carriers' possibility to grow their overall operations at London Heathrow appears limited, all the more as in the counterfactual, bmi's slots would be likely to be distributed across a range of carriers. Each of these carriers would be unlikely to obtain a very significant share of the slots at Heathrow [218] .
The Commission notes in addition that the notion of "slot hoarding" referred to by Virgin seems inadequate. Indeed, pursuant to the EU Slot Regulation, IAG has to use the slots acquired through the Transaction to provide services. Failure to use the slots to the extent required in the said Regulation would result in the slots falling back to the pool. Therefore, IAG could not simply "hoard" the slots to prevent competitors' expansion without offering services to consumers. Moreover, the Commission is not aware of any indication that IAG may have in recent years deliberately use slots in a non-efficient manner with the primary objective of keeping these slots and preventing other carriers from acquiring them [219] .
As regards the effect of the Transaction on IAG's shuffling power, and related ability to engage into exclusionary conduct, the Commission considers that the real effects of the Transaction on IAG's slot portfolio are too limited to materially increase such a shuffling power.
The Commission notes in this respect that the simulation provided by Virgin [220] analysed the effects of the Transaction on one aspect of IAG's shuffling power (i.e. its ability to move a flight to a timing close to the timing envisaged by a new entrant) on the basis of the expansion of IAG's slot portfolio by reference to the pre-Transaction situation, and not to the appropriate counterfactual. In addition to the fact that this simulation did not take into account the real slot portfolio of IAG and bmi (but instead, is based on a series of simulations randomly allocating the Parties' slots), this element makes this simulation inadequate to assess the real specific effect of the Transaction on IAG's shuffling power.