, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

As regards the application of Directive 91/670/EEC in the United Kingdom, the Commission stated that in order to clarify the situation, its services had contacted the United Kingdom Civil Aviation Authority. The complainant had been informed of this initiative and had been asked by the Commission services to forward to them details concerning his licence and experience.

The Ombudsman forwarded the Commission's comments to the complainant with an invitation to make observations. No observations were received.

The Decision

1.

Failure to answer correspondence

1.1. The Commission acknowledged that there was a failure to deal promptly with the letters sent by the complainant to its Representation in Madrid. It offered an explanation and apologised for the delay.

1.2. Furthermore, the Commission had instructed its Representations in the Member States to take all necessary measures to avoid such delays occurring in the future.

1.3. Since it appeared that a reply to the complainant's letters had been given, and that measures had been taken to avoid a similar situation, there were no grounds for the Ombudsman to pursue further this aspect of the case.

2.

Due diligence in ensuring compliance with Community law

2.1. In ensuring that Member States comply fully with Community law, the Commission should work in accordance with principles of good administration, and act with due diligence. This implies that the Commission, as the guardian of the Treaty, should actively seek that the concerned Member State puts an end to the alleged infringement and duly inform the complainant of its actions.

2.2. Following the letters of the complainant, the Commission services contacted the responsible national authorities in order to ensure proper application of Directive 91/670/EEC by the responsible British authorities. The Commission also requested more information on the complainant's problem, in particular as regards his pilot licence and professional experience.

2.3. From the available information, it appears that the Commission had acted with due diligence in the handling of this complaint. The Ombudsman therefore found no evidence of maladministration in relation to this aspect of the case.

On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

PRICE OF COMMISSION PUBLICATIONS

Decision on complaint 269/97/PD against the European Commission

The complaint