At the beginning of the 1990s, the question of whether age should play any part as a selection criterion was examined. After noting the undesirable consequences for the institution of abolishing all age limits, such as successful candidates reaching retirement age, the age limit was set at 50 for a whole series of competitions.
After 1995, arrangements for the joint organisation of competitions were made and harmonised conditions of access thereto, which included setting an age limit of 35 for candidates for posts at starting grades, taking into account the problems of unemployment of young people living in the European Union.
As regards the most recent competitions concerning the new Member States, the age limits were set at 55 and 45 to take account of the experience required for such posts.
Recently launched notices of competition provide for the possibility of extending the age limit for a maximum of six years in certain cases.
Rules governing age limits are not laid down automatically, but vary according to the nature of the department's needs, in accordance with the requirements of Article 27 of the Staff Regulations, and allow a distinction to be made between candidates to take account of their respective situations.
The General Secretariat of the Council considers that the application of age limits on the basis of the posts to be filled by successful candidates of a competition, as provided by the Staff Regulations, particularly Article 1(g) of Annex III, together with the possibility of an extension to take account of specific situations, is not a "discriminatory" measure in the sense given to this concept by the European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice.
For information, the General Secretariat added that it is currently in the process of discussing a proposal for an amendment to the Staff Regulations in respect of equal treatment(123).
Complainants' observations
The Ombudsman sent the Commission's opinion to seven complainants and the Council's opinion to one complainant for their observations. He received observations from three complainants. Two of them claimed that since the Commission has now acknowledged that the use of age limit is wrong and has made a policy decision in principle to abolish the age limits, the intermediate solution of raising the age limits to 45 years is in contradiction with this principle, and therefore unacceptable.