It was uncontested that the application of the rules in this case resulted in excessive costs for a limited number of potential participants in the written tests of the competition in question. Principles of good administration require that the administration proceed in a fair and just way towards all applicants in a competition. Organising a competition in a way which entails excessive costs for a limited number of applicants cannot be deemed to meet that requirement.
Conclusion
On the basis of the European Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, it appears necessary to make the following critical remark.
Principles of good administration require the administration to proceed in a fair and just way towards all applicants under competitions. In this case it appears that the Court of Auditors organised a competition in such a way that it entailed excessive costs for two applicants from one Member State (return air ticket of approximately ECU 1212). Therefore, by organising the competition in such a way, the Court of Auditors committed an instance of maladministration. It fell to the Court of Auditors to organise competitions so as to meet the requirement, for instance by organising more places of competition in order to shorten travel distances.
Given that this aspect of the case concerned procedures relating to specific events in the past, it was not appropriate to pursue a friendly settlement of the matter. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.
3.6. DRAFT RECOMMENDATIONS BY THE OMBUDSMAN
3.6.1. THE COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION
AN UP-TO-DATE LIST OF MEASURES ADOPTED IN THE FIELD OF JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS
Draft recommendation in complaint 1055/25.11.96/Statewatch/UK/IJH against the Council
The complaint
In November 1996, Mr B. complained to the Ombudsman that the Council does not maintain and make available to the public an up-to-date list of the measures which it adopts in the field of Justice and Home Affairs(119). The complainant claimed that in the interests of informing citizens and conforming to democratic standards the Council should maintain such a list and make it available on request.
The inquiry
The Council's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Council. In its opinion, the Council referred to the considerable efforts that it has made to improve the transparency of its proceedings in this context. In particular: