, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission stated that the validity of the reserve list in question was prolonged twice and finally expired on 30 June 1995. It was thus no longer possible to recruit Mr S., as the reserve list, on which he was placed, was no longer valid. The Commission furthermore recalled that according to the case-law of the Court of Justice, the fact that a person is on a reserve list does not entail an entitlement to a job with the Community institutions.

As for the complainant's allegation about a violation of fundamental rights, i.e. discrimination on grounds of nationality, the Commission firstly stated that the general rule, established by Article 27 of the Staff Regulations, is that no post can be reserved for a particular nationality. On the basis of reserve lists, the Commission services select those applicants whose professional profile appears to match the needs of the service, after which they make the corresponding proposal for recruitment to the relevant Directorate-General, DG IX. The Commission stressed that DG IX had not received any proposal concerning Mr S. Furthermore, the Commission referred to the fact that out of eight Belgians on the reserve list in question, four had been recruited.

Secondly, the Commission stated that in the context of the accession of the three mentioned Member States, the Council adopted Regulation (EC) No 626/95 to the effect that certain posts should be reserved for the holders of one of the three nationalities concerned. This Regulation thus constitutes a lawful derogatory measure to the general rule that no post is reserved for a particular nationality.

Concerning the use of temporary staff, the Commission stated that the budgetary authorities allocate permanent and temporary posts to the Commission and appropriations to employ auxiliary agents and service providers. Consequently, the use of this kind of staff does not affect the possibilities for recruiting civil servants to permanent posts.

The complainant's observations