The Commission also referred to the complainant's correspondence regarding the 1996 project. With reference to its letter of 18 June 1996, the Commission stated that NFF had been duly informed of the ECU 12000 limit for such subsidies, and that NFF was asked to submit a new application.
Regarding subsequent applications from NFF, the Commission stated that a search of the document registration system of the relevant Directorate-General showed no entries referring to an application or to correspondence in this respect. NFF later inquired about the subsidy. The Commission conceded that the reply, informing NFF that their application had been formally rejected, was mistaken. In a subsequent telephone conversation the Commission informed NFF that no application had actually been received and that it had become too late to make such application. On 23 September 1996, NFF enquired anew whether a subsidy for the 1996 project could still be given. They were informed that there was no possibility to fund the 1996 event.
The complainant's observations
In its observations, NFF maintained the complaint. Due to the Commission's letter of 9 January 1997 mentioning NFF's failure to account adequately for the spending of the subsidy in 1995, NFF extensively documented the way in which it accounted for the spending of the 1995 subsidy.
Further inquiries
In view of the different reasons given by the Commission for not granting the 1996 subsidy, the Ombudsman asked the Commission for further information.
In its second opinion the Commission stated that the question of whether to grant a subsidy or not was never considered, because no duly completed application forms were ever sent to the Commission.
The Commission added that, following NFF's complaint, the services responsible had reviewed their internal procedure in order to make it more formal, particularly as regards communication with applicants for subsidies.
In its observations on the Commission's second opinion, NFF maintained its complaint.
The Decision
The Commission in its two opinions did not maintain that a subsidy for the 1996 event was refused because of NFF's failure to account properly for the spending of the 1995 subsidy. The Ombudsman did therefore not inquire into the correctness of the Commission's view that NFF's accounting was faulty.