In its answer to this letter, the Commission stated that it had very often been criticised on the grounds of the high amounts it allocated to grant-holders and for failing to fully consider the existing conditions of the country where the research was carried out. According to the Commission, these issues had been discussed in the relevant programme committee, and taking into consideration the points raised by several delegations, the Commission decided the new amounts. The Commission pointed out that the new amounts were intended to provide coherence and equity with respect to grants used in other specific programmes of the fourth framework programme.
Other facts
It appeared from a complaint lodged with the Ombudsman on 23 September 1997, (complaint 855/97/PD) that given the drastic reductions of the current grants, one researcher had to abandon his research programme and return to his home country with his family.
The Decision
As concerned the first grievance about lack of information and communication with the grant-holders prior to the Commission's Decision, it shall firstly be observed that principles of good administration require that the administration shall deal with citizens in a fair and just way. This implies, among other things, that when the administration intends to take measures towards a limited and clearly identified number of citizens, the administration shall establish suitable contacts with the citizens concerned, making it possible for them to voice their opinion. It also implies that citizens shall be informed with due notice about the measures taken, so they can take adequate steps to adapt themselves to the changed situation.
In this case it appeared that there were no contacts between the Commission services responsible and the grant-holders. At the meeting of 11 July 1996 the grant-holders were simply informed about the possible reduction of their grants before the Commission actually took its Decision to that effect on 29 July 1996. When the grant holders were informed about the actual reduction that the Decision implied by the letters of 6 August 1996, the reduction had already taken effect. This way of proceeding appeared high-handed and arrogant and thus did not comply with principles of good administration.