, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The Commission replied on 12 January 1995, with an apology for the delay, that on the basis of the contents of the complainant's letter, it did not appear necessary to take any action under competition law. Not satisfied with the Commission's reply, the complainant wrote again on 23 January 1995 and received a similar reply on 1 February 1995. He wrote again on 28 April and 31 October 1995 and got an answer on 9 November 1995. In its replies, the Commission asked the complainant to provide more detailed information about the alleged violation of competition rules, and in particular indications on the companies involved in the alleged improper competition activities. The complainant finally sent three other letters on 21 November 1995, 29 March and 23 May 1996, but received no reply. In his letter of 21 November 1995 and further to the Commission's request for more detailed information, the complainant included a list with names and addresses of German and Austrian manufacturers practising sole agency agreements.

Given that the complainant received no reply to those last letters, he complained in July 1996 to the Ombudsman that the Commission:

1.

failed to take action further to his complaint alleging restriction of competition by German and Austrian model railway manufacturers;

2.

failed to answer his correspondence.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission in November 1996. In summary, the Commission made the following comments.

As regards the alleged failure to reply to the letters of the complainant, the Commission observed that it had recently replied to the letter of 23 May 1996. It annexed to its observations a copy of this reply dated 28 November 1996 and of the answer of the complainant.

  • celex=31993D0731