, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

As regards UCLAF, Mr P. referred to correspondence which he had forwarded to the Ombudsman in July 1997. UCLAF had requested him to supply copies of all the project's financial and administrative records. He had informed UCLAF that he considered the requirement to copy thousands of documents to be unreasonable, since LWL had no paid staff to undertake the work, and proposed instead a further on-the-spot audit in accordance with Article 39 of the contract.

The Ombudsman's attempt to achieve a friendly solution

On 8 September 1997, the Ombudsman wrote to the Commission with a view to seeking a friendly solution of the complaint.

The Ombudsman pointed out that, on the basis of the evidence in the file, the complainant did not appear to have received a reply to his claim that UCLAF's requirement that he supply copies of the records was unreasonable and his proposal that UCLAF perform an on-the-spot audit as an alternative. The Ombudsman suggested to the Commission that it either modify the requirement, or give reasons why it was necessary to insist on the copying of all documentation.

The Ombudsman's letter also drew attention to the fact that the Commission had not supplied to the Ombudsman the information requested concerning the reasons for non-eligibility of costs. Furthermore, the Ombudsman's inquiries had not yet convinced him that the Commission could provide a coherent account of why it believed that its view of the contractual position was justified. He suggested that, depending on the outcome of UCLAF's inquiries, the Commission might consider revising its stance in relation to the amount and payment of the final balance due under the contract.

In its reply of 12 November 1997, the Commission informed the Ombudsman that UCLAF was no longer demanding that LWL supply copies of the documents; that an on-the-spot inspection was to take place and that Mr P. had been informed accordingly. In relation to the contractual dispute, the Commission's reply stated that, for each periodic payment, the Commission had sent to LWL a letter including a financial table presenting both expenditure claimed and eligible expenditure, with the explanation of any difference. The Commission also stated that the legal basis for not having paid the final balance was that the Commission had not yet approved the final cost statement of LWL.