, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

An on-site visit to Itoiz by representatives of the services of the Commission took place on 23 June 1994. At the conclusion of the visit, the Commission representatives requested information and documents from Spanish local and central authorities; specifically, they requested justification of the overriding public interest of the project, analyses of alternative sites and locations considered before the decision to build the Itoiz reservoir, information on the irrigation projects, a formal promise that these projects would be subject to a full impact assessment procedure, and a debate open to all relevant interested parties where the compensation areas would be discussed.

In July 1994, the Spanish authorities presented a first set of documents concerning the hydrology of Navarre and a timetable for submission of the rest of the information requested. On 25 July 1994, Commissioner Mr Paleokrassas asked Minister Mr Borrell to postpone the execution of permanent works at Itoiz until the matter was settled. This request was accepted by the Minister by letter of 3 August 1994, and this standstill situation continued until the file was closed on 30 November 1994. On 21 September 1994 the Spanish authorities submitted a full set of documents concerning the overriding public interest of the project, the alternatives examined and the effect of the project on wild birds. On 4 October 1994 the Spanish authorities submitted a document on the compensation offered under Directive 92/43/EEC.

On 25 October 1994, at the Commission's initiative, the Spanish authorities organised a hearing on the Itoiz project in Madrid. All relevant interested parties were allowed to participate and actively defend their reasons in favour or against the project. TV, press and other media covered the event. The complaining association "Coordinadora de Itoiz" and its representatives were also present and participated in the debate. After the hearing, the Commission's services established a final report.

As concerned the complainants' allegation about an infringement of Directive 85/337/EEC, the Commission stated that an environmental impact assessment had been carried out by the Spanish authorities.