The Council was continuing to refuse access to certain documents on this ground. Mr B. referred in particular to the agendas of the "Senior level group" and the "EU-US Task Force". His confirmatory application for access to these documents, dated 28 July 1997, had been refused by the Council on the grounds that the agendas in question were established jointly by the presidency, the Commission and the United States authorities and that Article 2(2) of Decision 93/731/EC applied because the agendas in question were not prepared under the sole responsibility of the Council or its Presidency.
Further inquiries
After careful consideration of the Council's opinion and the complainant's observations, it appeared that further inquiries were necessary: firstly, in order to clarify the Council's position concerning the status of its presidency within the meaning of Article 2(2) of the Decision on public access to documents and, secondly, because the complainant's observations had raised a new issue; i.e. the refusal of the confirmatory application of 28 July 1997 for access to the agendas of the "Senior level Group" and the "EU-US Task Force".
The Council's response
In its response to the Ombudsman's request for further information about these matters, the Council stated that it does not consider its presidency to be "another institution", separate from the Council, within the meaning of Article 2(2) of Decision 93/731/EC. The Council went on to state that a distinction should be drawn between:
"documents written by the Member State holding the presidency in its capacity as presidency of the Council and
documents written by that Member State not relating to its role as presidency of the Council."
The Council also expressed the view that Article 2(2) of Decision 93/731/EC is applicable to the second category of documents.
As regards the agendas of the "Senior level group" and the "EU-US Task Force", the Council stated as follows: "The negative response to Mr B.'s request dated 28 July 1997 ... was not motivated by the fact that the presidency, which contributed to the establishment of the document, was considered as 'another institution' within the meaning of Article 2(2) of Decision 93/731/EC. In this particular case the agendas in question were not prepared under the sole responsibility of the presidency, but jointly by the presidency, the Commission and the United States authorities".
The complainant's complementary observations