Article 17(2) of the rules on the insurance of officials of the European Communities against the risk of accident and of occupational disease specifies that "The Administration shall hold an inquiry in order to obtain all the particulars necessary to determine the nature of the disease, ...". The Ombudsman noted that the European Parliament collected a large number of documents, mainly transmitted by the complainant, which permitted the writing of the very detailed mandate of the Medical Committee. He considered that there was no clear evidence that the inquiry made by the European Parliament lacked objectivity and aimed at prejudicing the complainant. There appeared, therefore, to be no maladministration by the Parliament in relation to this aspect of the complaint.
Failure to transmit some documents to the Medical Committee
2.1. After a careful examination of the material at the disposal of the Ombudsman, there appeared that some missing documents mentioned by the Parliament had in fact been stamped by the institution. The Ombudsman pointed out that it was good administrative behaviour for an institution to keep a clear registration of the documents it received. By not doing so, he considered that the European Parliament had failed in this principle.
2.2. The Ombudsman therefore examined the complainant's allegations that the failure of the European Parliament to transmit some documents to the Medical Committee obstructed the Committee from having a clear reasoning in writing its report. He first noted that some missing documents had in fact been transmitted to the Medical Committee given that they were mentioned in the Committee's report. He also noted that one of the members of the Medical Committee had been appointed by the complainant and, as it has been held by the European Court of Justice, "the interests of the official are safeguarded by the presence in the Medical Committee of a member enjoying his confidence and by the appointment of the third member of the Committee by agreement between the two other members appointed by the parties ..."(71).
2.3. On the basis of the above elements, it did not appear that the reasoning of the Medical Committee could have been vitiated and that the conclusion of its report would have been different. Therefore, the Ombudsman considered that there was no ground for a friendly settlement of the matter.
Avoidable administrative delay by the European Parliament