, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

In two letters to the Ombudsman of 20 May and 24 July 1998, Mr H. indicated that all the documents initially requested had already been forwarded to him, as proposed in the Ombudsman's initiative for a friendly solution. The complainant thanked the Ombudsman for the work undertaken and acknowledged the significant progress which had been made. In his view, the Ombudsman had done all that was within his powers and authority, and therefore he agreed to the closing of the case. Nonetheless, the complainant expressed some general concern as to the use of the documents which he had received, and more generally, to the procedure for public access to documents in the European Union.

The Decision

Following the Ombudsman's initiative, a friendly solution had been agreed between the institution and the complainant. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

TENDER EXERCISE FOR A POST OF FINANCE MANAGER UNDER THE PHARE PROGRAMME

Decision on complaint 1109/18.12.96/IGL/UK/IJH against the European Commission

The complaint

In December 1996, X made a complaint to the Ombudsman concerning a tender exercise for a post of finance manager under the Phare programme, carried out by DG 1A of the Commission. In accordance with Article 2(3) of the Statute of the Ombudsman, X requested that the complaint should be treated confidentially.

In summary, the relevant facts as presented in the complaint were that X was employed in Brussels as finance manager in a Phare programme coordination unit. In August 1994, the post was relocated to another country. After receiving informal assurances about the length of the prospective period of employment, X moved to the other country with his family. After approximately one year, the post of finance manager was subject to a tender exercise, in which X was unsuccessful.

In the complaint to the Ombudsman, X claimed that:

(i)

the tender exercise was not conducted in accordance with Phare regulations;

(ii)

the successful tenderer did not even closely comply with the terms of reference for the post;

(iii)

the successful tenderer had been in a position to know the level of the fees which X had previously received as finance manager.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. In its opinion, the Commission provided information about the organisational and contractual framework of the Phare programme.