, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

On 18 January 1995 Lord Plumb, Co-President of the ACP-EU Joint Assembly, sent a request for authorisation for Mr C. to take part in a mission to Paris. However, the late submission of this request meant that the Bureau did not have enough time to consider it and the mission went ahead without the required authorisation.

Parliament's Rules of Procedure are clear on this point and establish without any room for doubt that the request must be submitted in advance, and there is no provision for authorisation after the event. Under these circumstances I do not think that Parliament can pay the allowances and travel expenses to which Mr C. would have been entitled if the mission had been authorised by the Bureau.

None of this calls into question Mr C.'s good faith. I am sure that he only wanted to carry out his job as rapporteur to the best of his ability."

At a meeting with the Ombudsman's services, Mr C. confirmed that, as stated in his observations, he was not interested in the financial aspect of the matter. He indicated that his complaint was satisfied by the European Parliament placing on the public record that he had acted in good faith and that prior authorisation of the mission to Paris was indeed sought.

The Decision

1.

The European Parliament placed on the public record its acceptance that the complainant acted in good faith and that prior authorisation of the mission to Paris was indeed sought. The complainant for his part made clear that he did not seek to reclaim the expenses which the Parliament had required to be repaid on the basis of Rules 22(8) and 139(5) of Parliament's Rules of Procedure(67).

2.

It appeared from the above that, following the Ombudsman's initiative to seek a friendly solution, no issues remained in dispute between the complainant and the European Parliament. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

Further remarks

1.

The European Parliament did not formally contest the competence of the Ombudsman to deal with this complaint. However, it envisaged that future cases of this kind might be declared inadmissible and considered that the Ombudsman should not act as an "arbitration or appeal authority for Members whose requests are turned down by the competent parliamentary bodies."