, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Before the Ombudsman received the Commission's opinion, the complainants sent additional information by letters dated June and July 1997. The first letter referred to their contacts with different services of the Commission with a view to finding out the situation of the final payment for their project. Although final payment seemed to be on its way, the Commission had also pointed out to the complainants that it was within their power to block payments in case of doubt. In view of this statement, the complainants questioned in their letter to the Ombudsman whether there should be a deadline to limit that power.

In their letter of July 1997, the complainants stated that they had now received the final payment. They also stated that unless the Commission modifies its way of dealing with non-governmental organisations, they would be unable to participate in any other project. The complainants also thanked the Ombudsman for his efforts to achieve a successful solution to their problem.

The Ombudsman forwarded the Commission's opinion to the complainants with an invitation to make observations, but none were received.

The Decision

On the basis of the information provided by the complainants and the Commission, the Ombudsman concluded that the case had been settled by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

FAILURE TO KEEP A COMPLAINANT INFORMED OF DEVELOPMENTS CONCERNING HIS COMPLAINT

Decision on complaint 596/97/JMA against the European Commission

The complaint

In June 1997, Mr D. M. complained to the Ombudsman on behalf of an environmental group, CER. He alleged that the Commission had failed to inform CER of any developments concerning a complaint which it sent to the Commission in May 1996.

CER's complaint to the Commission concerned the authorisation granted by the Spanish authorities for mining exploitation in Montes Obarenes-Toloño, La Rioja. This area had been classified by the Spanish authorities as a Special Protection Area (SPA) for the protection of birds. On 5 June 1996, the Commission informed CER that the complaint had been registered under file number 96/4370 SG(96)A/8475, but had not subsequently forwarded any further information.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. The Commission's opinion was in summary the following: