, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The Commission subsequently provided further clarification to the Ombudsman. This was to the effect that the letter to the French authorities mentioned not only the Decrees relevant to Ladbroke's complaint dated 23 December 1992, but also those relating to its complaints dated 25 August 1994 and 27 March 1995. Furthermore, the letter also covered aid, referred to in a press release dated 10 December 1992 issued by the French Ministry of Agriculture.

It appeared from the complainant's observations on this further information from the Commission that they accepted that the concerns about possible maladministration expressed in his original complaint had been satisfied by the opening of a formal investigation under Article 93(2).

However, they expressed concern that the progress of the formal investigation should not be allowed to drift indefinitely, particularly in view of the absence of any binding time limits in the Commission's procedures. They stated that a further complaint to the Ombudsman might be made in case of excessive delay by the Commission in concluding its investigation under Article 93(2).

The Decision

1.

Article 155 of the EC Treaty establishes the role of the Commission as the "guardian of the Treaty". As guardian of the Treaty, its duty is to ensure that the provisions of the Treaty and the measures taken by the institutions pursuant thereto are applied. In the case of a new State aid which has not been notified in accordance with Article 93(3) of the EC Treaty, the Commission is empowered to apply the procedure of Article 93(2)(54).

2.

In dealing with a complaint in the field of State aids, the Commission is required, in the interests of sound administration of the fundamental rules of the Treaty relating to State aid, to conduct a diligent and impartial examination of the complaint(55).

3.

On 4 February 1997, the Commission began a formal investigation under Article 93(2) of Ladbroke's complaints concerning State aids to the French racing and betting industries. The investigation appeared to cover all the matters which were the subject of the complaint to the Ombudsman.

4.

The Ombudsman understood that the complainant accepted that the concerns about possible maladministration expressed in the original complaint to the Ombudsman were satisfied by the opening of the formal investigation under Article 93(2) on 4 February 1997.