A complaint made by fax dated 23 December 1992, concerning a grant of FRF 600 million which had not been notified to the Commission by the French Government as a State aid. By letter dated 12 May 1993, the Commission (DG IV) informed S. J. B. that the complaint would be dealt with under the number NN 35/93. S. J. B. received no further response from the Commission during the next three years.
A complaint made by letter dated 25 August 1994, concerning a further FRF 1500 million of aid which, according to press reports, the PMU was to receive over five years. S. J. B. received no response from the Commission to this complaint.
A complaint made by letter dated 27 March 1995, concerning a further grant of FRF 450 million to the French racing associations and the PMU which had been reported in the press. S. J. B. received no response from the Commission to this complaint.
S. J. B. claimed that the Commission had failed both to investigate Ladbroke's complaints and to enforce the obligation imposed on Member States by Article 93(3) of the EC Treaty to notify all new State aids to the Commission.
S. J. B. also informed the Ombudsman of certain other complaints that it had made to the Commission concerning other incidents of alleged State aid granted by the French authorities to French racing and betting undertakings. These complaints were the subject of judicial proceedings before the Court of First Instance, or in national courts. S. J. B. made no complaint to the Ombudsman in respect of the Commission's handling of these complaints and, in accordance with Article 138e of the EC Treaty and Article 1(3) of the Statute of the Ombudsman, they did not form part of the Ombudsman's inquiry.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Commission which sent its opinion on 28 November 1996. In summary the opinion made the following points:
The subject-matter of the complaint concerned French tax legislation in relation to racing betting levies, which was amended by five Decrees issued between March 1993 and December 1995. Six requests for information to clarify the matter were sent to the French authorities between January 1993 and November 1995.
Before taking a formal decision on Ladbroke's complaint it was first necessary to:
review the successive amendments to the French legislation,
ensure consistency in the Commission's response by considering other State aid cases of a comparable nature,