, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

The complainant is a supplier of EC documentation in Germany and receives material from OPOCE through the central German supplier, Bundesanzeiger. His main claim is that, as compared to the former situation in which citizens could order EC material directly from OPOCE, the present distribution system in which he can order only from Bundesanzeiger does not function efficiently. In particular, he alleged that documentation was sometimes not available and also that prices were too high. He also criticised the access to documents by Internet, which is not available to all citizens.

The inquiry

OPOCE's opinion

The complainant sent his complaint, addressed to the Ombudsman, to OPOCE. OPOCE transmitted the complaint to the Ombudsman, together with its opinion on the complaint.

In its opinion, OPOCE stated that it was necessary to supply publications and documents through a network of national distributors, since OPOCE itself could not possibly deal with all orders. This system is also intended to be closer to the citizens. OPOCE also pointed out that, given the large number of publications (15000 current titles and 700 new publications every year), it was impossible for all titles to be available at all times at all the national sales points. Therefore it was understandable that some of the publications the complainant wanted to order were not available. However, OPOCE underlined that it constantly promoted a quick client service.

As regards the cost of documents such as COM documents, OPOCE observed that prices differ from country to country due to the different costs of living in the Member States and the different means used by the national offices. OPOCE added that, in the debate between sale and free distribution of documents, the present policy of the institutions and of most of the Member States was based on sale. It also observed that it would soon make available a service of "document delivery" centralised by EUDOR, comprising the Official Journal of the European Communities, COM documents and other collections, which will apply the same charges for services to citizens in all the Member States.

As regards access through Internet, OPOCE stated that Internet access was parallel to, not exclusive of, other means of access to documents.

The complainant's observations