In November 1997, Mr K. made a complaint to the Ombudsman concerning the Selection Procedure COM/R/A/183 and the Selection Board's decision to nominate another applicant to the position despite the fact that the complainant was on the reserve list.
The complainant was a candidate in the Selection Procedure COM/R/A/183. On 3 March 1997, the Commission informed him that he was on a reserve list valid until 31 December 1997. In his complaint, Mr K. alleged that the position had in fact been created for a Mr H., although according to the complainant Mr H. did not comply with the requirements of the vacancy notice, that he neither had 15 years of work experience in the field nor was he the best qualified candidate.
The complainant claimed that he sent a fax to the Commission on 15 August 1997, asking about the filling of the vacancy. He also claimed that in order to eliminate possible candidates from other Member States, Finnish citizenship was required in the notice. Therefore, nobody except Mr H. stood a real chance of being recruited. Finally, he claimed that he was not informed of the nomination made pursuant to the Selection Procedure COM/R/A/183.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the Commission. The Commission's opinion can be summarised as follows:
The Selection Procedure COM/R/A/183, which aimed at constituting a reserve list for a position of Head of Unit at the Joint Research Centre in Petten, was totally transparent, objective and fair.
The abovementioned reserve list was established by the Selection Board acting within its margin of discretion. On the basis of that list, and by applying its discretionary powers, the Appointing Authority had to select the applicants fulfilling the required qualifications of the notice.
Five applications were presented. After having examined the files the Selection Board established that two applicants did not fulfill the criteria described in the notice. Three applicants were invited to interviews and the Board unanimously decided to propose to put Mr H. and Mr K. on the reserve list.
On 9 April 1997, the Selection Board met in Ispra in order to examine the two applications. The Board declared both applicants suitable for the position, underlining that Mr H. was better qualified in the marketing and administration of research projects for industry. This qualification figured on the vacancy notice.