However, despite Transaero having the necessary slots to continue to operate to Heathrow from Moscow, there is uncertainty as to whether IAG could operate both its own frequencies and bmi's frequencies on the London-Moscow route post-Transaction. The Commission understands that, under the UK/Russia ASA, if the second UK designated carrier does not operate, the first UK designated carrier cannot use the spare frequencies of the second UK designated carrier to operate on this route (i.e. IAG could not accumulate both its own existing 21 frequencies and bmi's 14 frequencies and use these 35 frequencies under its own license). However, the UK/Russia ASA is unclear on the question whether the first and the second designated carries could be part of the same group and operate under their individual operating licenses. Indeed, the UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) explained that bmi would not lose their status as the second UK designated carrier automatically post-Transaction (as a consequence of the fact that it would belong to the same group as the first UK designated carrier). However, other carriers might challenge bmi's operating license for this route post-Transaction. If that were to happen and if IAG was not prepared to voluntarily surrender bmi's route rights, a situation of "scarce bilateral capacity" would exist in which case the UK Department for Transport could ask the UK CAA to reconsider the licence of the incumbent carrier bmi and ask the UK CAA to hold a "scarce bilateral capacity hearing". The UK CAA explained that at such a hearing, the board of the UK CAA would decide which airlines should be designated and that "In making this decision the CAA will take into account the competitive situation and consider which carrier could sustainably provide the most benefit for consumers. If such a hearing were to be held the CAA would, amongst other factors, take into account whether carriers on a route may be under common ownership, as would be the case of bmi and British Airways (BA) post-Transaction, and would seek to consider the degree of “true” competition that might exist between them." [188] .
[…] [189] Furthermore, despite the slot lease agreement between BA and Transaero, there is uncertainty as regards bmi's right to operate its frequencies post-Transaction on the London-Moscow route.
Heathrow - Moscow