, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

[37] In its working paper of October 2011 on catchment area analysis, the CAA itself indicated that while catchment areas can provide useful evidence, they should not be taken as establishing which airports are within the same geographic market and supplementary evidence (notably on switching) would need to be considered when defining the relevant geographic market. It indicated in this respect that "Catchment area analysis is a way of estimating the geographic area from which a large proportion of an airport's outbound passengers originate, or inbound passengers travel to, and their geographic distribution within this area. The size of catchment areas and overlaps between catchment areas of neighbouring airports could provide useful evidence of the potential for, and strength of, competition between there airports. (…) By contrast, geographic market definition analyses the area over which passengers would substitute to other airports in light of a small but significant non-transitory increase in price of 5 to 10% above the competitive price level at the original airport".

[38] Civil Aviation Authority, "Airport Market Power Assessment, Passengers' Airport Preferences Results from the CAA Passenger Survey", working paper of November 2011.

[39] It must be noted that passengers were asked to state their response given their knowledge of the alternatives available from other airports.

[40] Commission's decision of 27 June 2007 in Case No COMP/M.4439 – Ryanair/Aer Lingus at recital 225.

[41] Commission's decision of 28 August 2009 in Case No COMP/M.5440 – Lufthansa/Austrian Airlines, recital 24 and following; Commission's decision of 22 June 2009 in Case No COMP/M.5335 – Lufthansa/SN Airholding, recital 36 and following.

[42] Commission's decision of 28 August 2009 in Case COMP/M.5440 – Lufthansa/Austrian Airlines, recital 25 and following; Commission's decision of 14 May 2009 in Case No COMP/M.5403 – Lufthansa/bmi, recital 17; Commission's decision of 22 June 2009 in Case No COMP/M.5335 – Lufthansa/SN Airholding, recital 37 and following; Commission's decision of 4 July 2005 in Case No COMP/M.3770 – Lufthansa/Swiss, recital 16 and following.