While the Commitments at issue - in the version submitted to the market test - have been generally evaluated in a positive way, several respondents questioned their effectiveness and ability to address the concerns raised by the Commissions in a full and comprehensive manner.
In particular, these respondents considered that a number of additional long-haul routes should have been included in the scope of the Commitments. Some respondents also highlighted the need to extend the scope of the "feeder routes" covered by the commitment (initially limited to European routes) to the whole of the routes operated by bmi pre-Transaction and in particular to routes to/from the Middle East.
The above-mentioned concerns have been comprehensively addressed by IAG in the final version of the Commitments, whose scope covers all routes that have been identified as potentially causing foreclosure concerns in respect of feeder traffic issues, both on the long-haul and on the "feeder" leg (which now includes all the routes operated by bmi pre-Transaction, to the extent that they will be operated by IAG post-Transaction as well as all intra European routes).
The fact that the SPA Commitment is not open to a given carrier if this carrier, either alone or in combination with alliance partners, has a hub at either both ends or at the non-London end of the route (depending on whether the route is "Category 1" or "Catgory 2") does not call into question the viability of the SPA Commitment. Indeed, in such cases, as already explained in section VI.3, IAG's incentives to reduce the feeder traffic provided to the carrier in question would be limited. Moreover, as regards the Category 2 routes, carriers that have a hub at the non London end of the route (and which will thus not be entitled to benefit from the SPA Commitment for this route) have not raised significant concerns during the market test of the Commitments.
The Commission considers that the SPA Commitment, addresses, in its principle, the serious doubts raised by the Transaction as regards a possible foreclosure strategy undertaken by IAG post-Transaction in relation to feeder traffic. Indeed, as a consequence of this commitment, IAG would have to enter into a SPA's with the carriers and for the long-haul routes for which a risk of foreclosure has been identified.