, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
589.

The Parties also submit that in order to be able to provide line maintenance services for a given aircraft model, a specific certification for that model is needed. However, this latter certification would be usually obtained in a short time-frame (approximately 1 month) and therefore would not represent a high barrier to entry for providers of line maintenance services for certain aircraft models that would like to expand their activities to other models. In this respect, the CAA explained that the timescale in which a licence would be granted depends on the level of the resources available and confirmed that for an existing organisation the timescale to gain any necessary approval would be considerably shorter.

590.

Moreover, if a wider geographic market were considered, the Transaction would not raise serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market, because the Parties would face significant competition from a larger number of suppliers at alternative regional airports, including in particular the other London airports as well as other UK airports. These suppliers include Storm Aviation, SR Technik, Virgin Engineering, Monarch Engineering, Thomas Cook, Thomas Airways, Apple Aviation,BCT, Delta Tech, Swiss Airlines, Air France (City Jet).

591.

Virgin expressed the view that post-Transaction IAG could restrict third party access to facilities owned by bmi at Heathrow (i.e. hangar bays and parking spaces) that are used by other airlines to provide MRO services, thus foreclosing competitors in that market and/or giving rise to increased barriers to entry/expansion and higher costs for other service suppliers. In particular, Virgin claims that some line maintenance activities need to be performed in a hangar, e.g. those relating to casualty repairs, which need to be remedied as soon as the defects are noted. Customer airlines would be therefore attracted to line maintenance services providers who can offer facilities to support such maintenance work in the event that a major defect is uncovered. As a consequence, IAG's acquisition of bmi's hangar bay at Heathrow would represent a competitive advantage […].

592.

With regard to the above, it should be underlined that the market investigation confirmed that, in principle, hangars are not essential for the line maintenance of aircrafts except during inclement weather or for lengthy fault rectification, certain complex tasks or particular scheduled maintenance tasks. [251]