The four main factor referred to by Virgin relates to exclusionary conducts, which would be facilitated by the increased number of slots held by IAG post-Transaction. According to Virgin, IAG's extended portfolio would increase its slot shuffling ability and correlatively, its ability to react to planned entries by moving flights to the same time as the new entrant's planned flights, or by increasing frequencies on the route, thereby forcing the new entrant to operate at levels at which it may be inefficient. In relation to this issue, Virgin provided a simulation model which tends to indicate that the additional slots obtained by IAG at Heathrow trough the Transaction would significantly increase its ability to deter entries or harm new entrants on routes on which it operates by moving flights to a timing that is as close as possible to the new entrant's envisaged timing. [213]
IAG also put forward arguments also essentially based on a review of relevant economic literature. IAG stressed that the majority of studies that found a hub premium are based on data for US domestic routes which pre-date relevant developments such as the emergence of low cost carriers. IAG pointed out that the limited number of studies that have been undertaken on routes from European hubs found little evidence of hub premia, and in particular, found none at Heathrow. IAG also argues that any hub dominance is likely to be undermined by competition from services operated at other airports serving the same city, which would be the case in London where there are four significant airports in addition to Heathrow. IAG eventually put emphasis on the distinction that would have to be made between higher fares that adversely affect consumers and higher fares that reflect quality and therefore benefit consumers.
2.2. Commission's assessment
In order to assess the specific effects of the Transaction on IAG's overall presence at Heathrow, it is necessary to take into consideration the number of slots that IAG would hold post-Transaction as compared to those it would hold in the counterfactual situation.