The Commission considers that the proper implementation of the plan should be supervised, particularly as regards the slimming-down of the balance sheet, the refocusing on core activities, the rationalization of those activities and CL's contribution to the hived-off vehicle in the form of a levy or dividends. In accordance with the rules on restructuring aid, the Commission takes the view that such aid should normally be necessary only once.
The French authorities will therefore have to submit the following documents to the Commission every six months:
a detailed report on the application of the plan, together with the reports submitted to Parliament;
the balance sheets, profit and loss accounts, and reports of the directors of the companies involved in the hiving-off operation, namely OIG, CDR, SPBI and CL;
a list of the hived-off assets that have been liquidated or sold, with details of selling prices, the names of purchasers, and the names of the banks to which selling instructions have been given;
a detailed list of abandonments of CDR claims to be set against the participating loan granted by SPBI;
a detailed list of the banking assets sold by CL outside the hived-off mechanism, together with an evaluation, based on objective and verifiable criteria, of the reduction in its commercial operations abroad;
detailed figures for CL's contributions to the hived-off structure in the form of a levy or dividends.
Any intention to amend the plan as communicated to and approved by the Commission, particularly at the time of privatization, will have to be notified to the Commission before it is carried out.
CONCLUSIONS
In conclusion, the capital increase carried out in 1994, the State's underwriting of the risks and costs of the transferred assets, as amended in 1995, and the other elements of the hiving-off mechanism contain appreciable State aid components within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty. The estimate of the discounted net cost to the State arising from the scheme is FF 5,2 billion for the capital increase and FF 36 billion for the underwriting. Given the uncertainty regarding certain aspects of the plan, a margin of variation of approximately 10 % needs to be incorporated into the value of the State intervention, leaving aside the capital increase. The maximum estimate of the discounted net cost is therefore FF 45 billion.