At the end of 1994 the tax group made up of CL and 71 of its subsidiaries had a loss carry-over of the order of FF 29 billion, the result mainly of the activities of the parent company in metropolitan France. According to CL's forecasts, the group's result for tax purposes should be slightly positive and should thus consume part of the tax loss which can be carried over for five years only, except for that part of the loss arising from the depreciation of property assets (i.e. FF 4,8 billion), which can be carried over indefinitely.
[. . .]
The French authorities have also confirmed that, in the event of a privatization of CL together with the probable transfer of the 'better fortunes` clause, the possibility of carrying over losses can in any case be reviewed in such a way as to make any such carry-over impossible.
(f) The Commission had stated that it could not declare total State cover which might undergo major variations to be compatible with the common market. Whilst it is aware that the precise cost of the underwriting to the State is very difficult to determine now, given the volatility of the value of the assets, the Commission must obtain an estimate of the final cost of the operation to the State, even within a range between two extreme values, in order to be able to assess compliance with the State aid rules, particularly as regards the limitation of the aid to what is strictly necessary and the compensating arrangements. In the event of the approved cost overshooting, the Commission will re-examine the case.
Furthermore, it should be pointed out that, as SPBI is a partnership with two partners - the State and Thomson SIEG - and Thomson SIEG's liability is limited to FF 1 000 according to SPBI's articles, the State remains solely responsible for SPBI's net liabilities. Although this liability is unlimited, the amount of SPBI's net liabilities can be estimated as the difference between CL's loan to SPBI (FF 145 billion) and SPBI's receipts, notably those from the zero-coupon bonds, the 'better fortunes` clause, the participating loan to CDR and the counter-guarantee provided by CDC and Thomson CSF against part of OIG's losses.