, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force
(iv)

present value of future income from the zero-coupon bond, some FF 8 billion;

(v)

total value of future income received by the State under the 'better fortunes` clause and in its capacity as a shareholder, corrected by the sensitivity analysis: estimated at FF 23 billion.

The balance of some FF 41 billion is the present-value estimate of the net cost of the mechanism to the State, and on which the Commission has based its examination of whether the aid is compatible with the common market. However, given the high degree of uncertainty concerning certain aspects of the plan, in particular with regard to CDR's losses and SPBI's future income, a margin of error of ± 10 % on the above costs (FF 36 billion excluding the capital injection) must be assumed. Accordingly, the estimate of the maximum net cost of the State intervention is FF 45 billion.

6.4. Other elements of assessment

The Commission notes the statement by the French authorities that it will be possible to consider privatizing CL only once the bank has recovered. Under the business plan presented by the French authorities, CL returns to viability in 1999. The Commission takes the view that the business plan is sufficiently realistic and achievable, at least until 2000. Accordingly, it also takes the view that privatization could take place after 1999.

On the basis of the information received from the French authorities, the Commission considers that the question of the role of Thomson SIEG and of CDC in the operation to support CL is not relevant to the questions that the Commission has to examine.

6.5. Distortion of trade between Member States

The liberalization of financial services and the integration of financial markets are making intra-Community trade more and more sensitive to distortions of competition.

Aid to an international bank such as CL, which provides loans and other forms of financing to firms that are in competition with one another on international markets and offers financial services in competition with other European credit institutions, while at the same time expanding its activities abroad through a network of branches outside France, is clearly liable to have a distorting effect on intra-Community trade. In particular, the aid in question enables CL to save and restructure a number of foreign subsidiaries, in particular in the Netherlands, Spain, Portugal and Germany, which are in competition with other Community financial institutions.