, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force

In evaluating the capital injections and the expected income in the form of dividends and/or capital gains, the discount rate must be the rate that the capital markets would have used in order to assess the return on their contribution.

According to estimates made by a number of experts, including CL, the appropriate rate of return for capital invested in a bank is of the order of 12 %. The same estimate may be arrived at by looking at the average rate of return over the last four years of a sample of major international banks (14). Thus, the target rate of return on own funds set by CL is of the same order of magnitude; the expected rate in 1999, after recovery, is 12,4 %. Accordingly, the Commission takes the view that a rate of 12 % may be regarded as appropriate for calculating the present value of future income for the State.

Three elements must be taken into account in arriving at an assessment of the net cost to the State of the operation. First, it should be noted that since SPBI is a partnership owned by the State, it enjoys a full guarantee by its shareholder. The aid component of the operation includes not only the losses on the participating loan in CDR but also the costs of financing SPBI.

Secondly, in the case at issue the method must be based on the fact that CL's value without the rescue plan would have been zero because its losses would have exhausted CL's own funds. Accordingly, the gross amount of the aid must include the zero-coupon loan, the income from the 'better fortunes` clause (the 'levy`) and the share of profits accruing to the State as a direct and indirect shareholder (Thomson and CDC), in the form of dividends and transfers to retained profits.

Lastly, it should be noted that the actual net financial contributions made by CL to the CDR/SPBI mechanism under the 'better fortunes` clause must be reduced by the tax revenue foregone by the State in order to enable CL to contribute to the costs of the operation. Since the clause is a levy on profits before French taxation, the State will forfeit the taxes normally due to it as the collector of taxes.

Accordingly, the aid comprises the following elements:

(i)

the capital injection;

(ii)

the waiver of the claim on CDR under the participating loan of FF 135 billion granted by SPBI and guaranteed by the State, after taking into account any income, the asset-carrying costs and the costs of restructuring the assets;