, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force

Nevertheless, the Commission believed that there were important points which needed clarification. Without further information, the Commission could not conclude that the plan was compatible with the common market. It also reaffirmed the general principles governing State aid to firms in difficulty, namely that aid be confined to the strict minimum so that the main recovery effort was made by the firm itself, that there should be a quid pro quo sufficient to offset the distorting effect which aid on this scale would have on competition, and that a restructuring plan enabling the firm to return to viability within a reasonable time should be fully implemented.

The Commission particularly asked for further information regarding:

(a)

the detailed lists of the assets transferred, referred to in the agreement concluded between the State and CL, and the assessments carried out by the consultant banks and by the Commission Bancaire;

(b)

the restructuring plan, broken down by activity and geographically, showing CL's return to viability;

(c)

the separation between CDR and CL, and the arrangements regarding CL's stake in the monitoring of CDR's management;

(d)

the arrangements for the repurchase by CL of the hived-off assets;

(e)

the possible carry-over of tax losses;

(f)

the total State cover for all of SPBI's liabilities;

(g)

the cost of restructuring the hived-off assets in order to sell them;

(h)

the conditions for privatizing CL, particularly regarding the future of the constraints imposed on CL following such privatization;

(i)

the possible condition regarding the withdrawal of SPBI's minority shareholders;

(j)

the sale of FF 100 billion of assets outside the CDR/SPBI mechanism;

(k)

any other sale on the periphery or in the field of CL's core activities;

(l)

OIG's activities in 1994, including, for example, its financial dealings.

It is necessary next to set out the information provided by the French authorities. That information was supplied in writing (letters of 26 and 28 April, 23 June and 6 July, registered on 27 April (A/33402), 3 May 1995 (A/33499), 26 June (A/34961) and 7 July (A/35317) respectively) or verbally during discussions between representatives of the Commission, the French Government and CL (held on 28 April, 17 May, 20 and 27 June, and 5 July 1995).