In the course of the discussions between the Commission's representatives and the French authorities, the latter reaffirmed their intention to privatize CL, explaining that the privatization process would be launched once the bank's economic and financial situation had been corrected. If the business plan is observed, CL's economic and financial situation will be restored, and the bank will again become viable, within five years.
The Commission takes a favourable view of the French authority's wish to privatize CL because this will help the recovery plan to succeed and will reduce the competitive distortions. Privatization will have the effect of limiting the life of the mechanism (20 years) and therefore the uncertainty over the risks and net costs of the mechanism. It will therefore reduce the scale of the aid; such a reduction will be guaranteed if the proceeds of privatization are paid to SPBI. At the same time, privatization will limit the distorting effect of the aid which would otherwise be spread over 20 years.
Given that any amendment of the plan's clauses, particularly at the time of CL's privatization, could have the effect of altering the final cost to the State, any such amendment will have to be notified to the Commission before it is carried out in order to enable the Commission to check that those amendments are compatible with the common market. The Commission will have to be notified if privatization is delayed for more than five years. Furthermore, the transfer of the participating 'better fortunes` clause against payment will have to be carried out at the market price, which will be independently assessed.
The Commission takes the view that, even if, for the State as shareholder, the sale of CL with or without these clauses does not in principle make any difference in economic terms (apart from the effect on the minority private shareholders), given that the transfer of the clause against payment will have the effect of increasing the selling price by an amount equal to its discounted value, the consequences for competitors may be different.
A sale to the public which is coupled with an announcement that the clause is to be cancelled should normally lead to a corresponding increase in the shares to be sold by the State which fully reflects the market value of that clause.
7.3. Monitoring and supervision of the implementation of CL's recovery plan