As regards the profit-sharing clause introduced to encourage CL to manage the hived-off vehicle well, the Commission considers that, once a clear separation between CL and CDR has been achieved, this clause will no longer be necessary and will therefore have to be eliminated, as the French authorities have already informally accepted.
7.2.2. Repurchase of the hived-off assets
With regard to the possibility of CL repurchasing certain hived-off assets, the Commission considers that the amendments to the rules on the management of CDR have not solved this problem.
The Commission considers that, in permitting CL to repurchase all or part of the transferred holdings at market prices after having transferred them to CDR at their book value just because it could no longer finance them - on the grounds that it could then still maintain its favourable commercial relationships with the enterprises in question - CL would benefit from the aid twice, an outcome which cannot be defended for competition reasons.
The Commission takes the view, however, that, if CL considers it appropriate to repurchase certain assets, that possibility should not confer an undue advantage on CL. In its opinion, therefore, CL should be able to repurchase hived-off assets, to the limited extent indicated in the contract of appeal objectives, only at the price at which the assets were transferred to CDR or at the market price if that is higher than the price at which the assets were transferred to CDR.
7.2.3. Carry-over of tax losses
The Commission applies the principles underlying the rules on restructuring aid to the carry-over of losses for tax purposes. Those rules stipulate that any loss offset by aid cannot be carried over for tax purposes. The 1994 losses, which correspond to the capital increase of FF 4,9 billion, cannot therefore be carried over for tax purposes.
With regard to residual tax losses, the Commission is asking the French authorities to rule out the possibility of a carry-over of tax losses for CL at the time of privatization if the 'better fortunes` clause is transferred.
7.2.4. Reduction of FF 100 billion of assets and sales in the banking network