Accordingly, a more prudent estimate should be made of CL's ability to stage a recovery. Naturally, this means that the forecast revenue for the State (income from the 'better fortunes` clause, and income accruing to the State as a shareholder in the form of dividends and transfers to retained profits) must be revised downwards by a sensitivity analysis based on the assumption of a nominal rate of growth of 2 % for profit after tax for the period 2000-2014.
6.3. Quantification of the amount of State aid
It is very difficult to quantify the cost to the State of rescuing CL because it is not easy to assess the aid content of the hive-off mechanism. It is not possible to give an accurate figure for the aid content of the State guarantee of the assets transferred to the hive-off vehicle because of the difficulties in quantifying the risk attaching to the assets. Producing a meaningful estimate of the aid content of the guarantee would require detailed valuations of all the hived-off assets. Such valuations can be carried out only by professional auditors. Accordingly, the Commission wished to examine the findings of the different assessments made by a number of experts, in particular the Commission Bancaire, CL's new auditors, and the advising banks.
An indicative estimate of the aid content of the State guarantee can be made by first looking at the amount of own funds that CL would have needed to satisfy the solvency ratio if the risk had not been underwritten by the State. The Commission made such an estimate when it opened the proceeding. The main purpose of the State cover of the total net value of the hived-off assets is to enable CL to remove the hived-off vehicle from its consolidated accounts, thus avoiding the need to make provisions (either to write assets down to their book value or to meet carrying costs) and to increase its own funds under the rules on the solvency of credit institutions, which would have had a substantial impact on the State budget.
Using information provided by the French authorities, this method has produced a more accurate estimate of the gross amount of the operation. The amount includes FF 4,9 billion of capital increase, FF 60 billion in provisions (12), and some FF 4 billion relating to the mechanical effect on the own funds requirements associated with deconsolidation, making a total of almost FF 69 billion.