On the liabilities side of the balance sheet, CL pursued, against a background of growing competition, a debt policy entailing high financing costs. A deterioration in the quality of its assets then caused the bank's rating to fall and added to its funding costs on the markets. At the same time, the rise in overheads continued to exceed the growth in total assets. In order to sustain CL's development, the French Government provided the bank, directly or indirectly, with considerable resources (more than FF 17 billion), particularly through transfers of public company securities and through cross-shareholdings (Rhône-Poulenc, Usinor-Sacilor, Aérospatiale, Altus). While this increased the bank's own funds for accounting purposes, it undermined the group's results owing to the low return on these holdings and the consolidation of the losses incurred by some of these enterprises.
The slowdown in economic activity, which caused property and stock market prices to fall and borrowers' situations to worsen, further accentuated the bank's problems. The interest margin narrowed appreciably, while long-term holdings in the industrial sector showed low or negative returns.
Following an initial examination of the case, the Commission had decided that the measures taken to support CL contained appreciable State aid components which could not be disclosed at that stage and which, on the basis of the information available at that time, were compatible with the common market.
GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF THE AID MEASURES
The measures taken by the French Government to support CL comprise a capital increase of FF 4,9 billion and the underwriting by the State of the risks and costs associated with assets transferred to a separate ring-fenced vehicle in what has been termed a 'hive-off` (opération de défaisance). Under the first rescue plan, which was put into effect in 1994, the State underwrote only FF 18,4 billion of the FF 42 billion of assets transferred. In 1995, with the transfer of further assets, the State has underwritten the entire net value of all the assets transferred in 1994 and 1995 (almost FF 135 billion) and the interest on the loan of FF 145 billion granted by CL to a public company named SPBI to finance the hived-off vehicle.