, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force

Thus, the assumption that CL can catch up with, and even overtake, its competitors by the end of 1999 in terms of its operating ratio seems optimistic. That would mean CL increasing its market share. However, it seems more realistic to suppose that the efforts made during this period by its competitors to improve their productivity will prevent CL from overtaking them. Catching-up is possible when there is wastage and inefficiencies that can be eliminated, but doing better than the competition would mean assuming that CL can introduce new management systems that are more efficient and more profitable than those of its competitors and with which they are not familiar. This objective therefore seems ambitious.

In addition, the planned improvement in costs must not be overestimated. In particular, any reduction in personnel costs in France is limited by the current system of redundancies, which makes it difficult to replace older staff with younger staff who are better prepared for the introduction, spread and intensive use of computerized systems. Although redundancy programmes have been drawn up with the agreement of the trade unions to encourage voluntary redundancies of excess staff, it would seem difficult to take further steps to keep and attract more valuable staff and to improve their productivity.

Alongside [. . .] is the fact that [. . .] covering 2000-2014 [. . .]. The business plan forecasts annual growth of 4 % for profits after tax; with annual inflation of some 2 %, that means an automatic annual real rate of growth of 2 % for net profits, ceteris paribus. It is clear that this arithmetical approach is not realistic. If there is only marginal growth in the banking sector, such an assumption implies growth in CL's market share. That is unacceptable.

For all the above reasons, it therefore seems more appropriate to assume that actual profits will be stable after CL's recovery. The rate of return on own funds assumed for 1999 (12,4 %) confirms CL's return to viability, whilst the automatic increases in the following years would seem overly optimistic.

  • celex=31989L0647