, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force

In 1995, under the second rescue plan, the hiving-off mechanism was adapted in order to allow for further potential losses that would have exceeded CL's original own funds. The French authorities have stated that the arrangement envisaged was carried out at the request of the Commission Bancaire and is the only one which would satisfy the many constraints imposed on a recovery plan: the protection of depositors, compliance with the provisions of banking, commercial and stock-exchange law, minimization of the cost of the plan to the taxpayer, avoidance of any distortion of competition; and the protection of the property of the State and of the minority shareholders.

They have also stated that the cost to the State of any alternative solution would be far higher, that complete State cover for the assets transferred is necessary if they are to be removed from CL's consolidated accounts and those accounts certified, and that the 'better fortunes` clause, together with the proceeds of asset sales, the zero-coupon bonds and the privatization of the bank, will meet the cost of the State cover provided, including the interest payable on the CL loan to SPBI.

The Commission, though, takes the view that the hiving-off mechanism, and in particular the cover of the risks and costs of the mechanism extended by the State, constitutes State aid. That it is State aid can be deduced from the fact that it is necessary to CL's survival, that its duration is unusually long, that the degree of risk is very high, and that no adequate return for the cover can be expected since it is subject to wide variations which CL is unable to meet.

On the basis of the available information, the Commission takes the view that there is no reason to believe that the total foreseeable cost of this mechanism to the French State is any lower than the cost to the State as a shareholder in the event of a supervised liquidation or any other solution involving sale or restructuring, bearing in mind the possible constraints imposed by national or Community rules governing the various possible scenarios. Those rules may mean that the costs of a liquidation are higher in the banking sector than in industry.