, Decision_act (EU) 1995/547

In force

For all these reasons, therefore, it seems more logical to assume that actual profits will stabilize after CL's recovery. The rate of return on own funds assumed for 1999 (12,4 %) confirms CL's return to viability, whilst the automatic increase assumed in subsequent years seems too optimistic. This means that the income from the 'better fortunes` clause and the revenue accruing to the State as a shareholder in terms of dividends or retained profits must be revised downwards. A sensitivity analysis based on the assumption of nominal growth of profits after taxation of 2 % gives an estimate for these two components of FF 15 billion and FF 10 billion respectively.

However, this estimate cannot be regarded as definitive because the State loses part of its normal tax take because of the clause. Account must be taken of this effect when calculating the cost of the State intervention since the intervention is justified by the possibility of benefiting from a return to better fortunes. Even though this tax concession is applicable to private and public investors alike, it applies only to firms in difficulty. In principle, therefore, such a concession constitutes State aid.

As mentioned above, the levy under the clause is applied before French taxes. Given that CL's tax losses have been deferred for five years and that almost half CL's revenue is generated abroad, the shortfall of taxation can be estimated at 17,5 % of the present value of income from the clause from 2000 to 2014, or FF 2 billion. This amount must be deducted from the present value of the clause. Accordingly, a more accurate estimate of the value of the 'better fortunes` clause is FF 13 billion.

>TABLE>

To sum up, the estimates of the different components of the operation to rescue CL are set out below:

(i)

capital injection with a present value of FF 5,2 billion;

(ii)

waiver of claim by SPBI on CDR under the participating loan; maximum amount FF 135 billion and estimated at FF 60 billion, after taking account of the income and carrying costs and restructuring costs of unprofitable assets and assets with low profitability;

(iii)

the net carrying cost of other hived-off assets, FF 7 billion, i.e. the difference between the cost to SPBI of the loan granted by CL (FF 11 billion) and the income for SPBI from the participating loan granted to CDR (FF 4 billion).

The following costs of the mechanism should be taken into account: