The advisory committee has very extensive powers. It will have to express a view on all major decisions committing CDR or its subsidiaries and concerning, for example, sales of assets, additional financing operations or disputes which exceed thresholds laid down in the agreement and which may subsequently be amended by the committee's rules of procedure. Although, legally speaking, these opinions are merely advisory, they have the effect, if negative, of ruling out financial responsibility on the part of SPBI. In practice, the advisory committee will have the power to reject such operations.
In completing its tasks, the committee will be able to carry out audits of assets or transactions effected. In particular, selling instructions will, unless expressly approved by the committee, be entrusted to third-party banks to ensure an independent evaluation. This safeguard will also apply to the management of assets, which, if necessary, will be entrusted to another establishment.
As regards the profit-sharing clause designed to encourage CL to manage the hived-off structure well, the French authorities have made it known informally that the article of the agreement relating to that clause will not be implemented.
(d) With regard to the possible repurchase by CL of certain hived-off assets, Annex 12 to the agreement requires any selling instructions to be entrusted to third-party banks and CL will have to request the express and prior agreement of SPBI before acquiring an asset. Particularly in the case of a planned sale to a third party other than the CDR group, a purchase by CL must be carried out on terms, especially regarding price, that at least match those proposed by the third party other than the CDR group. In the event of a spontaneous sale at any time as part of the management of the assets, SPBI will be able to require CL to compete with third parties. In this case and in the case of the sale of the hived-off banks, the price of acquisition by CL will, if SPBI so requests, be set jointly by two commercial banks, appointed by CL and SPBI respectively as competent experts.
(e) The Commission had also taken the view that the possibility open to CL to carry over tax losses was a problem which had to be dealt with according to the principles laid down in the rules governing restructuring aid. The complainants also called for this possibility to be eliminated.