(b) In its decision to initiate the procedure, the Commission requested that it be provided with CL's recovery plan to enable it to assess the compatibility of the aid, and in particular the capital increase. The Commission requested more detailed financial information on CL's various economic and geographical sectors of activity in order to establish that the aid did not exceed what was strictly necessary and that CL could return to viability without further support from the State in the future. This information is essential if the Commission is to determine whether or not CL's reference scenario for the next five years is realistic and, in particular, if there is a prospect of reducing CL's operating ratio (that is to say the ratio of overheads plus depreciation to net receipts from banking) in four years from its current level of 81 % to a level below that of its main competitors (i.e. around 70 %), thereby producing a corresponding improvement in CL's results.
The French authorities have transmitted the business plan drawn up by CL. With a view to restoring CL's capacity to generate profits, the business plan analyses the main problems responsible for the bank's difficulties, namely excessive and poorly controlled growth, runaway overheads and insufficient control over exposure. Following this analysis, the plan divides into three main areas: