If the bank cannot be recapitalized by its shareholders or purchased by another institution, various solutions are possible: filing for bankruptcy, application of a mechanism for a controlled liquidation or sale by lots, or collective intervention by a number of other banks with the aim of preventing the possible undesirable negative effects mentioned above. If, without being under any obligation to do so, the private sector also invests substantial sums in a rescue operation, it may be concluded that no State aid is involved.
According to the scale of the possible crisis affecting the financial system, the supervisory authorities may act. In the case of publicly-owned banks, the State may also be called on to intervene as a shareholder.
If the State is providing all or most of the financial support, even at the request of the supervisory authorities, the Commission has to evaluate any State aid component in the measures taken by the State. Here, the Commission generally applies the test of the private market-economy investor as set out in its communication on public undertakings (3). That communication states that there is an aid component in a transaction if it would not have been acceptable to a private investor operating under normal market conditions.
Turning to the question of public holdings in company capital, the Commission made clear its view in a 1984 communication (4) that such a transaction would not be acceptable to a private investor, and that the presence of aid could therefore be presumed, where the financial position of the company is such that a normal return (in dividends or capital gains) cannot be expected within a reasonable time from the capital invested or where the risks involved in such a transaction are too high or extend over too long a period.
In the same way, the Commission takes the view that there is a presumption of State aid in a State guarantee if the guarantee is necessary to the survival of the company - in other words, if the aid component is equal to the amount guaranteed - and if it lasts for an exceptional length of time or entails a very high level of risk.