As mentioned above, the compatibility of such measures with the common market has to be assessed in accordance with the special rules on aid for rescuing and restructuring firms in difficulty, with account also being taken of the effect of State intervention on the financial system in the Member State concerned. In the particular case of banking, the Commission takes the view that rescuing and restructuring aid may be compatible as long as the four conditions set out above (point 3.2) are met.
The Commission has to establish, in particular, whether the distorting effect of the State aid on competition is offset by anything solid compensation in the restructuring plan. Such a quid pro quo is necessary if the aid is not to be declared contrary to the common interest.
Given the colossal amount of aid involved, which is also intended to cover the losses incurred from assets acquired by CL during its period of aggressive expansion in the 1980s, CL's contribution must be both substantial and accompanied by a reduction in its commercial presence; at the same time, the need to restore and maintain CL's viability has to be met. This contribution must contain a real and substantial quid pro quo for the further reason that the bankruptcy solution is ruled out since it would have an undesirable and disproportionate negative impact on other credit institutions and on the financial markets. That solution would probably have been adopted in the case of any non-banking private enterprise recording such colossal losses. The competitive distortion created by the aid is therefore very marked and must be matched by a corresponding quid pro quo. It should be pointed out that the deficit will not be made up, even after 20 years, by the projected profits.
7.2. Questions arising from the Commission's assessment and conditions governing acceptance of the aid
7.2.1. Separation between CL and CDR
In the light of the amendments made by the French authorities to the mechanism for controlling CDR, as described above, the Commission considers that the danger of a conflict of interests arising will be eliminated if the committees and the team leaders are independent of CL. The teams themselves should be financially answerable to CDR. It is also necessary to ensure that the committees responsible for managing the hived-off assets are independent of CL.