, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

6.7. The practical arrangements for the cooperation between the Commission and the United Nations are still fragile and unstable. In order to guarantee consistency, stability and clarity in the relations with all the agencies, a global agreement could usefully be made with the United Nations' Secretariat-General, specifying the prospects and the practical details of the collaboration with the Commission's departments (see paragraphs 2.23, 2.24 and 2.28). An agreement of this kind would clarify the special relations with the United Nations. These would, furthermore, be improved if ECHO took greater account in its framework partnership agreement of the operational realities of these organizations, which differ very considerably from those characterizing most of the non-governmental organizations (see paragraph 4.21).

Mobilization of large-scale resources

6.8. In a particularly strained situation, the Commission was able to mobilize just over 2 000 Mio ECU in conjunction with a large number of partners who on the whole recognized that the aid thus received was crucial. The Great Lakes crisis showed that ECHO was able, in conjunction with the United Nations agencies and other partners, to mobilize considerable resources within reasonable time-limits. In this respect, it should be noted that coordination with bilateral aid measures has not given rise to large-scale joint measures (see paragraph 2.21).

Procedures for evaluating and for rendering the accounts

6.9. The evaluations carried out between 1992 and 1995 related to the implementation of measures within the framework of individual operational contracts. In this context, the Commission has never given the evaluators a mandate to examine the way in which its own departments worked. Furthermore, whereas the Commission implements global plans for aid measures, the evaluations are not carried out with a view to an overall appraisal of the implementation of each plan. It is at this level, however, that the budgetary authority can appraise whether the mobilized funds have in fact contributed to the set objectives. It is therefore up to the Commission to set up a mechanism for appraising the substance and the impact of humanitarian aid measures; this is something which ECHO's annual reports, with their still basically statistical approach, are unable to provide (see paragraphs 5.2 and 5.3).

Final consideration