2.20. The Community should also clarify what is meant by the term coordination as used in Article 130x of the Treaty (27) (28). Depending on the circumstances, the term can, in fact, cover very different measures and coordination may range from simple, one-way transmission of information to the systematic pooling of resources that have been mobilized in a coordinated way. It may also consist of making the best use of the capabilities of one or other of the parties, where they are relatively advantageous, by judicious allocation of tasks and resources (see paragraph 1.10).
2.21. Whereas in the area of development aid the Court of Auditors usually found that, on the ground, there was a certain amount of coordination between the Commission's representatives and those of the Member States (29), this did not apply to humanitarian aid. In the only case where large-scale operations were attempted (European Community Task Force - ECTF, see Box 1), cooperation dwindled rapidly, because of a lack of adequate commitment on the part of the Member States. The bilateral aid that was already in place was continued on an individual basis, alongside the ECTF, by the Member States concerned. In this context, in Croatia, at the end of 1994, there was found to be no effective coordination, with the result that bilateral food aid was distributed to the same recipients as the Community aid.
Box 1 - ECTF - European Community Task Force, Zagreb
>START OF GRAPHIC>
The ECTF was set up in October 1992 during the European Council in Birmingham 'to support the efforts of the UNHCR to deliver humanitarian aid to the former Yugoslav republics'.
Its objectives were:
2.21.1. to provide logistical and technical support to the UNHCR (although the latter was not consulted as such);
2.21.2. to improve coordination on the ground, principally by facilitating, between donors, the exchange of information on actions funded, with there being an implicit obligation on the Member States and the Commission to inform the ECTF of all their actions.
ECHO, by integrating its own bureau in Zagreb into the ECTF, gave it the additional objectives of implementing the direct food aid actions in Croatia and of supervising the Commission's partners.
From the outset, the planned information exchange proved difficult. Some Member States even initiated actions directly within the responsibilities of the ECTF without consulting it.