, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997

5.10. The Joint Evaluation of Emergency Assistance to Rwanda (see paragraph 1.14) shows how pressure from the media and within the aid agencies results in inflationary estimates of numbers of refugees/displaced persons. For example, the initial estimate used in July 1994 for planning purposes by the UNHCR and the WFP for the number of refugees in Goma was 1,2 million, although the source of this figure is not known. In August, on the basis of aerial photographs and surveys the estimate was revised downwards to 850 000, and in September it was estimated that the number of persons requiring food rations was 740 000. This turned out to be about the numbers involved when the refugees were registered by the UNHCR in January 1995.

5.11. It is clear that the most effective way of determining numbers is to register all the refugees or displaced people. Registration can be combined with information-gathering on the characteristics of the refugee population, which is of considerable value in determining more closely what their requirements are, and in involving them in the planning and management of the assistance programme. Accurate estimates of numbers requiring assistance are essential for effective provision and management of humanitarian assistance. As one of the major donors, the Commission should insist on registration by the responsible agency as soon as possible after a crisis arises.

5.12. At the level of individual operations, paragraph 3.13 indicates important weaknesses in the information available on the intended beneficiaries in individual project proposals. Out of the 35 evaluation reports of ECHO examined which address this issue, 10 underline that the agency had not carried out an adequate needs assessment and had not targeted the aid sufficiently. Where an action is an immediate response to an urgent crisis, there may be insufficient time to carry out sophisticated targeting initially, but when a crisis is protracted it is both feasible and essential. Examples of inadequate targeting include providing assistance too widely rather than concentrating the aid on those in real need, and failing to target beneficiaries in the areas of most need.