, Special Report No 2/97 concerning humanitarian aid from the European Union between 1992…

In forcesince 20 Feb 1997
c)

even though the UNHCR's ability to monitor the final distribution of goods on the spot was limited, ECHO accepted implementation reports which were very general and whose information value was low, despite the fact that only the individual operations were regarded as eligible;

d)

despite the size of the amounts involved, ECHO has not obtained from the UNHCR independent evaluations of the operations financed.

For the crisis in Rwanda, an examination of four agreements made with the UNHCR for a total of 73 Mio ECU gives rise to the following observations:

a)

the Commission's agreements do not correspond to the UNHCR's programmes of operations; this is simply a consequence of the fact that the Commission has made appropriations available gradually;

7Y0512(01).1

b)

by deferring the expiry of the agreements by several months and accepting that only one overall report be submitted for the four agreements, the Commission has adapted the standard system which it initially set up to the operational needs of the UNHCR in this crisis. ECHO's various contributions can be seen as a piecemeal response to a global appeal, a system which the Commission is usually against;

c)

the UNHCR has not always responded to ECHO's requests for information: for example, as at September 1995 it had not sent ECHO all the agreements made with the NGOs;

d)

because of the large number of operations and because the detailed information is dispersed, the system which ECHO has set up does not enable it to exercise its operational and financial control under the conditions provided for by the framework partnership agreement. Notwithstanding these points, the manner in which the Commission provided block funding to the UNHCR in Rwanda was judged effective in the circumstances by the evaluators mentioned in paragraph 1.14 above.>END OF GRAPHIC>

4.16. However, although the purpose of the framework partnership agreements is to establish cooperation which is geared towards effective action, simplified administrative procedures and a higher profile on the scene of crises, the number of these agreements tends to be restricted by two constraining factors: ECHO's limited human resources and the need to have a thorough knowledge of its partners' capabilities and working methods.